Why Opportunity Depends on What You’re Looking At
As a member of Generation X, I grew up in an era when we didn’t have smartphones, social media, streaming services, or an app to give us the answer to everything.
If we didn’t know something, we had several choices. We could look it up in an encyclopedia, ask someone who might know, or simply remain confidently incorrect until someone proved us wrong.
Somehow, we survived.
We also had Risky Business.
There’s a memorable moment in that movie when Tom Cruise’s character is encouraged to occasionally say a certain three-word phrase beginning with “What the…”
Today, we’d probably just text WTF and save ourselves the other letters.
But beneath the very Gen X delivery was actually a useful idea: sometimes, you need to look at a situation differently.
I’m certainly not suggesting we use Risky Business as our investment policy statement. That could make for an interesting conversation with the compliance department.
But changing our perspective can be valuable, especially when we’re talking about investments.
Which Market?
We frequently hear someone say:
“The market was up today.”
Most of us immediately know what they mean; they’re talking about the stock market.
But there isn’t just one market.
There are stocks, bonds, real estate, oil and other commodities, gold, cryptocurrencies, cash, and money-market instruments.
All of them exist within the same financial environment, but they don’t necessarily respond to that environment in the same way.
That’s why one of the most useful questions we can ask isn’t simply:
What is the market doing?
It might be:
Which market, and why?
Same Economy, Different Perspectives
Consider interest rates.
Someone earning more interest in savings may look at higher rates very differently from someone trying to finance a house.
A real estate investor may have another perspective entirely.
And a business considering borrowing millions of dollars to expand may see those same rates differently again.
Nobody necessarily has to be wrong.
They’re simply experiencing the same financial environment from different positions.
Oil provides another easy example.
When oil prices rise, an energy producer and an airline may have quite different reactions.
One may benefit from higher prices. The other may be looking at a potentially higher operating expense.
Same oil price. Different consequences.
That’s why describing a financial development as simply “good” or “bad” can sometimes miss the bigger picture.
A better question might be:
Good for whom?
Different Investments Tell Different Stories
This principle extends across the investment world.
Stock investors may be focused on what businesses can earn in the future.
Bond and credit investors may be much more interested in financial obligations and the ability of borrowers to meet them.
Real estate investors have their own considerations.
Gold has historically attracted attention for reasons very different from stocks or real estate.
Cryptocurrencies introduce another set of possibilities and risks altogether.
Even cash has a role in the conversation.
The purpose isn’t to decide that one of these investments is always better than the others. It’s to recognize that they’re different.
Sometimes, understanding those differences can help us better understand what’s happening in the financial world around us.
Even the Same Company Can Look Different
Here’s where the idea becomes particularly interesting.
Two investors can study the exact same company and focus on completely different things.
A stock investor may see growth and future opportunity.
A credit investor may be much more concerned about the company’s financial obligations and its ability to meet them.
Same company. Different questions.
Neither perspective necessarily tells us everything we need to know.
But looking at something from another investor’s perspective can occasionally reveal something we weren’t paying attention to before.
That’s an idea we’ll return to another time because I think there’s much more to explore there.
Gold, Crypto, and Alternative Investments
Gold and cryptocurrencies also remind us why labels can sometimes be dangerous.
Both may be described as “alternative” investments, but that certainly doesn’t make them the same thing.
Gold has been part of financial markets for centuries. Cryptocurrency is a much newer development.
People may consider either of them for vastly different reasons or with very different expectations.
The important educational question isn’t necessarily whether one is better.
It’s:
Why am I considering it in the first place?
“I heard it’s going up” may be an answer.
I’m just not sure it’s a particularly worthwhile investment thesis.
Although, judging by several centuries of financial history, it’s certainly a popular one.
Investments Don’t Exist in Isolation
This brings us to the bigger lesson.
Investments don’t operate in separate universes.
Interest rates can influence businesses, real estate, and financial markets. Oil prices can affect producers, consumers, and companies. Inflation can mean different things to borrowers, savers, businesses, and households.
Changes in one part of the financial system can eventually influence another.
That doesn’t give us a formula for predicting which investment will perform best next.
That’s not the objective.
The objective is understanding that the pieces are connected.
Maybe What We Need Is an Investment Tutor
People sometimes assume financial education should eventually produce an answer to one question:
“So, what should I buy?”
That’s not really how I think about what I’m trying to accomplish with CaseWorth Capital.
I sometimes think of my role more as an Investment Tutor.
A good math tutor doesn’t simply write the answer at the bottom of the page. The tutor helps the student understand the problem well enough to work through it.
I think investment education can work the same way.
My job isn’t to tell someone whether stocks, bonds, real estate, oil, gold, cryptocurrency, or something else is “the answer.”
It’s to help people better understand what they’re looking at, recognize that different investments may respond differently to the same financial environment, and become more comfortable asking questions before reaching conclusions.
Because if I simply give someone an answer, I’ve helped with one question.
If I help someone learn how to think through a financial question, that knowledge can be used again.
And again.
That’s a much more interesting educational goal.
Maybe “The Market” Isn’t the Question
The next time someone tells you:
“The market is doing well.”
Consider asking:
Which market?
Stocks?
Bonds?
Real estate?
Oil?
Gold?
Cryptocurrencies?
Cash?
Then perhaps ask one more question:
Why?
We don’t need to know exactly what happens next to become better students of investing.
Sometimes, we simply need to learn to look at the same financial environment from a different perspective.
As a Gen Xer, I’m still perfectly comfortable borrowing a little philosophy from Risky Business from time to time.
But when it comes to investing, the better question isn’t WTF?
Maybe it’s:
What changed, and why?
Okay, technically that’s four words.
Apparently, even Gen X needs an editor occasionally.
Applied knowledge is your best asset.
It Is a Financial Journey, Not a Financial Guess.
Educational purposes only. This article is intended to support financial education and discussion. Nothing presented should be considered investment, tax, legal, or financial advice.